A Coaching Audit Should Be a Mirror, Not a Report Card





A Coaching Audit Should Be a Mirror, Not a Report Card

Professional development should develop the coach—not exhaust the coach.

By Keith F. McAdams
World Championship Habits

I have spent a significant part of my life coaching, studying coaching, attending clinics, completing certifications, and continuing my education.

I believe strongly in coach education.

But I have also come to believe that we sometimes confuse the amount of work required to complete professional development with the value of the professional development itself.

They are not the same thing.

A coach can spend hours traveling to a clinic, sitting in a classroom, completing assignments, producing documents, and demonstrating that he or she knows the accepted answers.

At the end of that process, an important question remains:

Did the coach actually become a better coach?

That question has become increasingly important to me as we have been developing the World Championship Habits Coach Audit & Development Program.

And it has led me to a simple principle:

A coaching audit should be a mirror, not a report card.

Coaches Usually Know the “Right” Answer

This became very clear while we were developing our assessment process.

Ask an experienced coach whether players should be treated fairly.

Ask whether practices should have objectives.

Ask whether coaches should communicate effectively.

Ask whether player development is important.

What do we expect them to say?

Of course they know the answers.

Most experienced coaches know what they are supposed to say.

That does not necessarily tell us what happens on Tuesday afternoon when practice isn't going well, the team is tired, a talented player isn't executing, a parent is complaining, or the coach has ten minutes left to accomplish something that was supposed to take thirty.

That is where philosophy becomes behavior.

And that distinction matters.

Research in sport coaching has identified a similar problem. Coaches' perceptions of their own behavior do not necessarily correspond perfectly with what actually occurs. Research using systematic observation has therefore argued for examining coaching behavior as a way of helping coaches develop greater self-awareness. (Frontiers)

So perhaps one of the most important questions in coach development is not:

What does the coach know?

It is:

What does the coach actually do?

Knowledge Matters. Execution Matters More.

I have told players and coaches versions of this for years:

You usually know what you're supposed to do.

Knowing is not always the problem.

Executing it consistently is the problem.

A coach may genuinely believe in player autonomy while controlling every decision in practice.

A coach may believe that mistakes are part of learning while immediately correcting every mistake.

A coach may believe in development while allowing short-term winning pressures to determine decisions.

A coach may believe that players should think for themselves while designing practices in which players rarely have to make a decision.

That doesn't necessarily make someone a bad coach.

It makes that coach worth examining.

There can be a gap between our intentions and our execution.

Good professional development should help us see that gap.

There Should Be No Grade

This is where I think traditional assessment can sometimes send the wrong message.

If I give an experienced coach a developmental assessment and tell that person he or she received a C, what have I accomplished?

Perhaps embarrassment.

Perhaps defensiveness.

Perhaps motivation.

But not necessarily development.

The objective should not be to prove that my coaching philosophy is better than yours.

There is more than one way to coach successfully.

Different sports, ages, cultures, competitive levels, athletes, organizations, and circumstances require different approaches.

Research on systematic observation in coaching has raised this same contextual issue: coaching behaviors should not simply be detached from their circumstances and classified universally as “good” or “bad.” Researchers have instead argued for using behavioral information collaboratively to help coaches understand their own practice and stimulate reflection. (Frontiers)

That is much closer to what I believe a coaching audit should accomplish.

The questions become:

What are you doing now?

What are your strengths?

Where are the gaps?

Are important pieces missing?

Does what you do match what you say you believe?

And what would help you improve?

That's a profile.

Not a grade.

Reflection Needs Something to Reflect Upon

Telling coaches to “reflect” sounds good.

But reflect on what?

Research suggests that reflective practice can be valuable in coach development, while also showing that coaches do not necessarily know how to use it effectively without appropriate structure or support. One study of experienced coaches found that coaches were already using aspects of reflection without necessarily recognizing them as reflective practice; structured intervention helped deepen that process. (PubMed)

A separate four-week study involving 83 coaches found positive effects from online reflective journaling, with statistically significant improvement in reflection in the experimental group. (PubMed)

That suggests an important practical principle:

Reflection becomes more useful when we give the coach something meaningful to examine.

Instead of saying:

Think about your coaching.

We can ask:

When this happens, what do you actually do?

How frequently does this occur?

Which of these actions describe your normal practice?

Does your behavior match the philosophy you say you hold?

Now reflection has an anchor.

Maximum Developmental Value. Minimum Unnecessary Work.

There is another side to this that matters tremendously to me.

Coaches are busy.

Some coach professionally.

Others teach.

Some have another full-time career and coach because they love it.

Some run organizations while coaching teams.

Some are completing advanced degrees.

Some are raising families.

Professional development requires effort. I'm not arguing against hard work.

I am arguing against unnecessary work.

During the development of our own coaching audit, we encountered this problem ourselves. It became possible to collect enormous amounts of information.

But eventually we had to ask:

Just because we can collect it, does that mean we should?

If a developmental program requires so much time that good coaches will never finish it, we haven't created a rigorous program.

We've created a barrier.

Interestingly, researchers examining systematic observation for coach development have made a related practical point: full observation instruments can be time-consuming and are not always feasible or necessary for professional development. They have argued for refining and focusing tools so coaches can engage with them more autonomously. (Frontiers)

That principle resonates with me.

The goal should be:

Maximum developmental value with minimum unnecessary workload.

Not minimum effort.

Not shortcuts.

Not lowering standards.

Removing work that doesn't contribute enough to development.

Identify. Develop. Reassess.

I increasingly see coach development as a continuing cycle rather than an event.

Identify where you are.

Recognize strengths.

Find developmental opportunities.

Identify important pieces that may be missing.

Provide resources that address those areas.

Apply what you learn.

Then come back later and look again.

Research supports the broader importance of this reflective cycle. Studies have connected reflective practice with self-awareness, learning from experience, behavioral change, and coach development. (PubMed)

The purpose isn't to finish professional development.

I'm not sure a serious coach ever does.

The purpose is to know what to work on next.

The Mirror

That's ultimately why I like the metaphor of a mirror.

A good mirror doesn't criticize you.

It doesn't congratulate you.

It doesn't give you a grade.

It shows you something.

Then you decide what to do with what you see.

I think professional development should do more of that.

Give coaches an accurate picture of their current practice.

Recognize what they're doing well.

Help them discover what they may not be seeing.

Give them credible resources to improve.

Then allow them to return later and ask:

Have I changed?

Because ultimately, the purpose of professional development should not be to prove that a coach completed professional development.

It should be to help that coach develop.

And if we can accomplish that while respecting the coach's time, experience, individuality, and circumstances, we may not only produce better coach education.

We may produce better coaches.

Yes. The problem is that I left editorial commentary inside what should be the finished article. The reader shouldn't see phrases such as “the research base is strong enough” or “I would include.”

At the very end of the article, after your name and World Championship Habits, it should simply read like this:


References

Cope, E., Cushion, C. J., Harvey, S., & Partington, M. (2022). Re-visiting systematic observation: A pedagogical tool to support coach learning and development. Frontiers in Sports and Active Living, 4, 962690.
Frontiers — Read the study

Nash, C., MacPherson, A., & Collins, D. Reflections on reflection: Clarifying and promoting use in experienced coaches.
PubMed Central — Read the study

Da Silva, E. J., Evans, M. B., Lefebvre, J. S., Allan, V., Côté, J., & Palmeira, A. (2022). A four-week online coach education program improves the quality of coaches' reflections.
PubMed — Read the study



Keith F. McAdams
World Championship Habits



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

THE FUTURE VISION THAT MADE SEFA TAKAR A CAPTAIN

Devotional: God's Word Never Returns Empty

A COACHING PROFILE SHOULD DO MORE THAN GIVE YOU A SCORE