World Championship Coaching Principles: The Tolls Principle
World Championship Coaching Principles: The Tolls Principle
Every worthwhile goal has a price.
If you want to improve fitness, you have to train. If you want to become a better hockey player, you have to practice. If you want to build a successful team, players, coaches, parents, and organizations will have to give something—time, effort, energy, money, comfort, attention, or opportunity.
I call those costs Tolls.
A Toll is the price paid while pursuing a goal.
The important question is not whether there will be a Toll. There usually will be.
The important questions are:
What is the Toll?
Who is paying it?
What are we receiving in return?
Is it still worth paying?
And if the Toll has become too high:
Can we change the method without changing the standard?
That last question became extremely important to me while running a youth hockey fitness program in Tampa.
What Is the Tolls Principle?
The Tolls Principle teaches that every goal, plan, program, and decision carries a price.
Some Tolls are necessary.
Some are productive.
Some are temporary.
Some increase over time.
Some are difficult to see when a program begins but become evident after the program has operated for a while.
That means a coach cannot simply design a program and assume that because it worked once, it should remain unchanged.
You have to keep reading.
A good goal does not automatically make every method of reaching that goal good forever.
Conditions change.
Players change.
The environment changes.
When that happens, the Toll can change too.
The Tolls Model
GOAL → PLAN → IDENTIFY TOLLS → EXECUTE → MONITOR → REEVALUATE → ADJUST → CONTINUE
The model begins with the goal.
What are we trying to accomplish?
Then develop the plan.
What will we do to accomplish it?
Next, identify the Tolls you can reasonably anticipate.
Then execute the plan and monitor what actually happens.
That last part matters because you will not identify every Toll on paper.
Some become visible only through experience.
When the evidence changes, reevaluate.
Then decide whether to continue paying the Toll, reduce it, change the method, or redesign part of the program.
Not Every Toll Is Physical
In sports, it is easy to think of Tolls only in terms of physical workload.
How hard did we train?
How tired are the players?
How much recovery do they need?
But the total Toll can be much larger.
There can be physical Tolls.
Mental Tolls.
Time Tolls.
Transportation Tolls.
Financial Tolls.
Family Tolls.
Academic Tolls.
Work Tolls.
Social Tolls.
Scheduling Tolls.
A workout can be excellent and still be part of a poor overall structure if the total price required to execute it becomes too high.
The coach therefore has to evaluate more than the workout.
You have to evaluate the entire system surrounding the workout.
The Tampa Bay Fitness Program
One of the clearest examples came during a youth hockey fitness program I ran in Tampa.
Fitness mattered to me.
It was part of the standard.
But by the third year of the program, I could see that the Tolls associated with the way we were delivering the program had become too high.
This wasn't something I discovered after one difficult week.
We had three years of experience.
That history mattered because now we had evidence.
And the circumstances surrounding the players had changed.
All of the players were older.
Many had part-time jobs.
Others were playing other sports.
New players had been added to the roster, including players coming from farther away.
They still had school.
They still had hockey.
They still needed fitness development.
But now school, jobs, other sports, transportation, family responsibilities, hockey, and fitness training were all competing for the same limited time.
The objective had not become wrong.
The conditions surrounding the objective had changed.
And the Tolls were now evident.
I knew we needed to make a change.
Listen to the Problem Without Giving Away the Standard
I met with the players and parents.
They had legitimate issues with the existing structure.
I agreed with them.
That matters.
Listening to somebody's concern does not automatically mean lowering your standards.
Their concerns about the method were legitimate.
But fitness itself was not negotiable.
The players still needed to meet the fitness standards required by the team.
That gave us a very important distinction:
Fitness was non-negotiable. The method was negotiable.
That distinction changed the conversation.
We were no longer debating whether fitness mattered.
We were solving a program-design problem:
How can we maintain the fitness standard while reducing unnecessary Tolls created by the current method?
That is a completely different question.
The Price of Changing
There was another side to the decision.
Changing the existing method also carried Tolls.
If I was going to give players greater responsibility for their own strength training, I had to ask:
What price could we pay if these athletes were not properly trained in the fundamentals of lifting?
I could reduce transportation and scheduling Tolls and accidentally create a much worse problem.
I was not going to hand players a workout program and simply tell them to go lift weights.
They had to know what they were doing.
Poor technique, inappropriate loads, poor progression, and inadequate supervision can create unnecessary risk.
So changing the method required preparation.
Build the New Route
We established a baseline test.
We needed to know where each player was starting.
Before progressing, each player had to demonstrate that he could correctly execute the required lifts.
We taught the fundamentals.
We established training partners.
We developed a 12-week training program.
The players began with lighter weights.
The purpose was not to see how much weight they could move as quickly as possible.
They needed to learn how to perform the movements correctly and establish sound training habits before increasing the load.
This was an important part of the solution.
We did not reduce one Toll by carelessly creating another.
We built the new route before expecting the players to travel it.
Agreement Creates Responsibility
The change was not simply announced.
I met with the players and parents.
We discussed the problems.
We discussed the standard.
We discussed the new method.
And we reached agreement about how we would move forward.
The players would execute the 12-week program during the summer months before school started.
That timing mattered.
Summer gave us a better opportunity to establish the new system before the academic demands of the school year returned.
The players understood what they were responsible for.
The parents understood the structure.
I understood what I was responsible for providing.
The method changed, but responsibility did not disappear.
Accountability Remained
Greater independence did not mean:
Do whatever you want and we'll hope it works.
We established accountability.
Players went to a designated gym for monthly testing.
They also completed self-testing that was due by Monday morning.
They could complete it before Monday, but by Monday morning it had to be there.
Now we had evidence.
We had the baseline.
We had the training program.
We had monthly testing.
We had weekly self-testing.
We could compare results.
We could see whether the program was being executed.
We could see whether the fitness standard was being maintained.
That is critical.
If you change a method because you believe the Toll is too high, you still have to determine whether the new method works.
Evidence Before Ego
One reason coaches sometimes keep paying unnecessary Tolls is because changing a program can feel like admitting the original program was wrong.
I don't see it that way.
The original program existed under one set of conditions.
Three years later, the conditions were different.
The players were different.
Their responsibilities were different.
The roster was different.
And we had three years of information that we did not possess when we started.
Why would I ignore that evidence?
The purpose of a program is not to prove that the coach was right.
The purpose is to help the players develop and perform.
When the evidence tells you the method needs to evolve, use the evidence.
What the Research Supports
The word Tolls is my coaching vocabulary.
Sports science does not need to use my terminology for the underlying principle to have support.
Research and professional guidance in athlete development support several ideas behind the Tolls Principle.
An athlete's total load extends beyond the demands of a single workout.
Training, competition, psychological stress, travel, school, work, recovery, and other demands can interact.
Athlete-load monitoring is valuable because it helps coaches understand how athletes are responding to training and competition and provides information that can be used when programs need to be modified.
Youth resistance-training guidance also supports qualified instruction, correct exercise technique, appropriate starting loads, gradual progression, and appropriate supervision.
The research does not prove that every coaching decision in the Tampa program was the only possible solution.
It supports the broader principle behind the decision:
Training should be evaluated within the total demands being placed on the athlete.
Non-Negotiable Standard. Negotiable Method.
This may be the most important lesson from the entire example.
Coaches sometimes make one of two mistakes.
They become so rigid about the method that they refuse to change anything.
Or they hear resistance to the method and immediately lower the standard.
There is another option.
Keep the standard. Change the method.
Fitness remained non-negotiable.
How we developed, monitored, and organized that fitness could change.
That distinction protects standards while allowing innovation.
The workout is not the objective.
The schedule is not the objective.
The system you created three years ago is not the objective.
The objective is what matters.
There Is a Toll on Both Sides
Every decision has a price.
Keeping the old program had a Toll.
Changing it had a Toll.
Greater independence had a Toll.
Greater control had a Toll.
More travel had a Toll.
Less supervision had a potential Toll.
There was no choice where everything became free.
That means the decision cannot simply be:
Which option has a Toll?
They probably both do.
A better question is:
Which Toll is worth paying for the result we are trying to produce?
In Tampa, reducing transportation and scheduling demands created a need for greater education, preparation, personal responsibility, and accountability.
We accepted those Tolls because they gave us a better route toward the same objective.
Common Mistakes With Tolls
A coach can misuse this principle by treating every inconvenience as an excessive Toll.
That is not the idea.
High performance requires work.
Players will become tired.
Families will make sacrifices.
Training requires time.
Discipline is sometimes uncomfortable.
A difficult Toll is not automatically a bad Toll.
Another mistake is lowering the standard when the method is the real problem.
Another is continuing a method simply because it worked in the past.
Another is removing one Toll while unknowingly creating a larger one somewhere else.
And another is changing the method without providing the education, structure, or accountability required to make the new method successful.
The goal is not to make everything easier.
The goal is to make the system better.
How to Use the Tolls Principle
When evaluating a program, ask:
What are we trying to accomplish?
What is non-negotiable?
What is negotiable?
What price are we currently paying?
Who is paying it?
What benefit are we receiving for that price?
Have the players or circumstances changed?
What happens if we continue the current method?
What is the potential Toll of changing it?
Can we reduce an unnecessary Toll without lowering the standard?
What preparation will the new method require?
How will we know whether the change actually worked?
Those are performance questions.
They force us to look beyond tradition and examine what is actually happening.
Make the Work Evident
A change should eventually produce evidence.
In Tampa, that meant we had ways to evaluate what happened.
Baseline testing gave us a starting point.
Weekly self-testing gave us ongoing information.
Monthly testing gave us another accountability point.
Technique standards told us whether players could execute the lifts correctly.
Fitness standards told us whether the objective was being achieved.
The new system could therefore be evaluated rather than merely defended.
Don't change simply to change.
Change for a reason, then look for evidence that the change improved the situation.
If it did, continue.
If it didn't, adjust again.
Where Tolls Fits Within World Championship Habits
World Championship Habits is built around development, execution, evidence, feedback, and continuous improvement.
The Tolls Principle protects that process from becoming rigid.
A program can be well designed and still need to evolve.
A standard can remain correct while the route used to reach it becomes inefficient.
Tolls gives the coach another lens for evaluating performance:
What are we asking people to pay, and what are we producing in return?
That question applies to training, schedules, travel, meetings, education, recovery, team rules, personal development, and organizational structure.
It keeps the focus on the purpose of the program rather than blindly protecting the program itself.
The Tolls Principle
Every worthwhile goal has a price.
Great coaching is not about eliminating that price.
It is about understanding it.
Some Tolls should be paid.
Some Tolls develop discipline, capacity, skill, and character.
Some are simply part of pursuing excellence.
But circumstances change.
Players change.
Programs evolve.
And sometimes a Toll that once made sense no longer produces enough value to justify its cost.
When that happens, don't automatically lower the standard.
Look at the method.
Listen to the people involved.
Study the evidence.
Identify what is non-negotiable.
Identify what can change.
Prepare people properly for the new route.
Establish accountability.
Then measure what happens.
The standard can be non-negotiable while the method remains negotiable.
Keep the goal.
Know the price.
And when the evidence shows there is a better route, be willing to take it.
Comments
Post a Comment