INFLUENCE WITHOUT CONTROL

 



INFLUENCE WITHOUT CONTROL

How to Guide, Encourage, and Challenge People While Respecting Their Responsibility to Choose

PART THREE: HOW WE INFLUENCE PEOPLE | ARTICLE 5

HOW TO LEARN, TEACH, AND INFLUENCE PEOPLE

By Keith F. McAdams

World Championship Habits

A coach possesses authority.

The coach can establish expectations, organize practices, assign roles, determine playing time, select the team, and impose appropriate consequences.

But authority does not give a coach control over another person’s mind, commitment, or choices.

I can explain why something matters.

I can provide evidence.

I can demonstrate the required action.

I can ask questions.

I can create opportunities to practice.

I can recognize progress.

I can correct poor execution.

I can establish consequences when a player knowingly violates a team standard.

But I cannot make the player accept the lesson.

I cannot force someone to care.

I cannot make another person take ownership.

The player must choose.

That creates one of the most important distinctions in coaching, teaching, parenting, counseling, and leadership:

WE CAN INFLUENCE THE OPPORTUNITY, UNDERSTANDING, ENVIRONMENT, AND PROBABILITY.

WE CANNOT MAKE ANOTHER PERSON CHOOSE.

Influence respects that boundary.

Control attempts to cross it.

Influence Is Not the Same as Control

Influence helps another person see, understand, consider, and act.

Control tries to remove the other person’s responsibility to think and choose.

Responsible influence may include:

  • Teaching.

  • Explaining.

  • Demonstrating.

  • Listening.

  • Asking questions.

  • Sharing evidence.

  • Clarifying expectations.

  • Recognizing good work.

  • Correcting harmful behavior.

  • Establishing boundaries.

  • Applying appropriate consequences.

  • Creating another opportunity to act.

None of those actions guarantees that the person will respond as we hope.

A coach may teach clearly and still have a player reject the instruction.

A parent may provide wise guidance and still have a child make a poor decision.

A teacher may create an excellent learning opportunity and still have a student refuse to participate.

A leader may act honestly and still face disagreement.

That does not mean influence failed.

It means another person remains responsible for their choice.

INFLUENCE CREATES AN OPPORTUNITY FOR A BETTER DECISION.

IT DOES NOT OWN THE DECISION.

What I Wanted My Players to Learn

Throughout my coaching career, I did not want players to accept information merely because the head coach said it.

I wanted them to study.

I wanted them to ask questions.

I wanted them to challenge information respectfully.

I wanted them to examine whether an idea was true, useful, and appropriate for the situation.

I wanted them to take what they learned and make it their own.

Sometimes my instruction was direct because the situation required immediate execution.

Other times, I wanted the players to research a problem, explain what they discovered, and contribute to the solution.

I would tell them:

“Go find something that works.”

That did not mean every answer was equally good.

The information still had to be examined.

The idea had to fit our purpose, principles, players, and situation.

The player had to be able to explain why it might work.

Then we needed to test it through action.

This process gave players a voice, but it did not eliminate standards.

It gave them responsibility.

There is an important difference.

Giving someone a voice does not require the leader to surrender leadership.

Allowing questions does not mean every decision becomes a vote.

Respecting choice does not mean removing consequences.

The head coach remains responsible for the program.

The player remains responsible for the choice.

Players Eventually Leave the Coach’s Environment

During a national-team camp, I could organize the schedule, meetings, practices, recovery, expectations, and learning environment.

I could observe the players.

I could provide reminders.

I could correct problems.

I could recognize good work.

But national-team players eventually returned to their club teams, schools, families, and daily lives.

I was no longer standing beside them.

The environment changed.

The reminders changed.

The demands changed.

If the player’s behavior depended entirely on my presence, then I had not helped the player develop ownership.

The lasting test of influence was not whether players followed instructions while I watched them.

The test was whether they could recognize what mattered, make a responsible decision, and act when the coach was not present.

That is why I wanted players to understand the purpose behind the work.

Why does preparation matter?

Why do focus and effort matter?

Why does recovery matter?

Why does supporting a teammate matter?

Why should the player study the game?

Why does one habit make the next action more likely?

The purpose was not to keep the player under the coach’s control.

The purpose was to help the player develop enough understanding, character, and self-direction to make better choices independently.

THE GOAL OF INFLUENCE IS NOT DEPENDENCE.

THE GOAL IS RESPONSIBLE OWNERSHIP.

Clear Leadership Still Matters

Influence without control does not mean passive leadership.

A coach cannot simply present several possibilities and avoid making a decision.

Leadership sometimes requires a direct instruction:

“Protect the middle.”

“Come off the ice when your shift is finished.”

“Treat your teammate respectfully.”

“Be ready when your opportunity begins.”

A player may not have complete freedom within every situation.

Team membership includes responsibilities.

Roles have expectations.

Actions have consequences.

The coach has an obligation to protect the team, the player, the learning environment, and the standard.

But even when an instruction is direct, the player still chooses whether to follow it.

The coach controls the instruction and the appropriate response to the player’s action.

The coach does not control the player’s internal decision.

This distinction protects both responsibility and accountability.

The player cannot say:

“My choice was the coach’s fault.”

The coach cannot say:

“I can make this player choose correctly.”

Each person must take responsibility for what belongs to them.

Responsibility Has Boundaries

A leader needs to understand the boundary of responsibility.

The Coach Is Responsible For:

  • Preparing.

  • Teaching accurately.

  • Providing a clear picture.

  • Explaining the purpose when appropriate.

  • Listening before assuming.

  • Matching the method to the person and situation.

  • Establishing clear expectations.

  • Creating useful opportunities to practice.

  • Giving honest feedback.

  • Applying fair consequences.

  • Examining whether the process is working.

  • Taking responsibility for the coach’s words and conduct.

The Player Is Responsible For:

  • Listening.

  • Asking when something is unclear.

  • Examining the information.

  • Preparing.

  • Choosing.

  • Practicing.

  • Executing.

  • Responding to correction.

  • Accepting appropriate consequences.

  • Evaluating the result.

  • Taking the next responsible action.

These responsibilities affect each other, but they should not be confused.

A poor response from the player does not automatically prove that the coach taught poorly.

A correct explanation from the coach does not automatically prove that the player learned.

We examine both sides.

THE COACH OWNS THE INFLUENCE.

THE PLAYER OWNS THE CHOICE.

BOTH ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR THEIR ACTIONS.

Persuasion Must Remain Truthful

Dale Carnegie’s influence principles include understanding another person’s perspective, connecting an idea to that person’s interests, asking questions, encouraging ownership, and presenting a purpose that can inspire willing action.

Those ideas can support responsible influence.

But they require an ethical boundary.

Understanding what someone wants should help us communicate truthfully.

It should not become a way to exploit fear, insecurity, ambition, or the desire to belong.

A coach should not create false urgency.

A coach should not threaten a consequence the coach has no authority to impose.

A coach should not pretend that the player originated an idea merely to secure agreement.

A coach should not use public humiliation to force compliance.

A coach should not hide important information because the truth might make persuasion more difficult.

The purpose is not to make another person say yes.

The purpose is to help the person understand the truth well enough to make a responsible decision.

A useful working definition is:

PERSUASION IS HELPING SOMEONE UNDERSTAND A TRUTHFUL REASON TO CHOOSE A USEFUL ACTION WILLINGLY.

Persuasion may increase the probability of commitment.

It cannot guarantee agreement, ownership, or action.

Agreement Is Not Ownership

A player may nod during a meeting.

That does not prove agreement.

A player may agree verbally.

That does not prove understanding.

A player may understand.

That does not prove commitment.

A player may intend to act.

That does not prove execution.

The progression is:

HEAR → UNDERSTAND → EXAMINE → CHOOSE → ACT → EVALUATE → OWN

A coach can support every part of that progression.

But the learner must eventually carry it.

This is why I wanted players to explain ideas in their own words, teach their linemates, and execute without waiting for another reminder.

Ownership becomes evident when the person can continue the behavior without depending entirely on external pressure.

Too Much Control Can Reduce Ownership

A coach may believe constant direction demonstrates strong leadership.

But if the coach makes every decision, supplies every answer, identifies every mistake, and provides every correction, the player may never learn to think independently.

The player can become dependent on the coach.

What do I do?

Where do I go?

Was that correct?

What should I change?

The coach may be producing immediate compliance while preventing long-term ownership.

The better progression is:

COACH DIRECTS → PLAYER PARTICIPATES → PLAYER EXPLAINS → PLAYER CHOOSES → PLAYER EXECUTES → PLAYER EVALUATES → PLAYER SELF-CORRECTS

The amount of direction should fit the person and situation.

A beginner may require more instruction.

An immediate danger may require a direct command.

A team system requires shared responsibilities.

A deliberate violation may require a consequence.

But whenever possible, the learner should gradually carry more responsibility.

The goal is not to remove the coach.

The goal is to develop a person who can act responsibly when the coach is absent.

What the Evidence Suggests

Self-Determination Theory distinguishes between controlling pressure and support for autonomy.

Autonomy does not mean that people operate without expectations, instruction, structure, or responsibility.

It means that people experience some ownership of their actions rather than acting only because they feel forced.

Edward Deci and Richard Ryan’s work explains that meaningful reasons, acknowledgment of a person’s perspective, and a sense of choice can support the internalization of values and behaviors. Their work does not suggest eliminating structure. It connects autonomy with competence and relatedness as important psychological needs.

Research in sports has also examined autonomy-supportive coaching. Studies associate autonomy-supportive coaching with stronger forms of motivation and athlete engagement. Experimental work with coaches preparing athletes for the 2012 London Paralympic Games found that coaches could be helped to use a more autonomy-supportive approach even in a high-pressure environment.

That evidence does not prove that every choice-based message will work or that direct instruction is harmful.

It supports a more careful conclusion:

People may be more likely to internalize and sustain useful behavior when leaders provide meaningful reasons, listen to their perspective, maintain appropriate structure, and leave room for responsible ownership.

The objective is not maximum freedom or minimum leadership.

The objective is leadership that helps a person develop the ability and willingness to act responsibly.

Influence Can Change the Environment

We cannot control another person’s choice, but we can examine the conditions surrounding that choice.

Is the expectation visible?

Is the required action understandable?

Has the behavior been demonstrated?

Does the person have the ability to execute it?

Are reminders available?

Does the environment recognize good work?

Does the environment tolerate conduct that contradicts the stated standard?

Is the desired behavior easier or harder than the behavior we are trying to change?

Are there opportunities to practice the choice before pressure increases?

These questions do not eliminate personal responsibility.

They help us determine whether the environment supports the decision we are asking someone to make.

Influence changes probability.

It does not create certainty.

Influence Through Environment, Mastery, and Compete

Environment

Create conditions that make the desired action visible and possible.

Clarify the standard.

Provide reminders.

Model the behavior.

Recognize its execution.

Remove unnecessary obstacles.

Mastery

Help the person develop the knowledge, understanding, skill, and habits required to carry out the choice.

Let the person ask questions.

Allow appropriate examination and disagreement.

Teach the person how to evaluate the result.

Compete

Allow the person to choose and execute under pressure, resistance, uncertainty, fatigue, and consequences.

The coach cannot make the decision for the player during the moment of competition.

Preparation influences the choice.

Character and habit become evident through the action.

The World Championship Habits Influence Process

Use this process:

UNDERSTAND → CLARIFY → PRESENT → INVITE → CHOOSE → EXECUTE → OBSERVE → ADJUST

Understand

Learn enough about the person, need, and situation to know what may be influencing the present behavior.

Clarify

State the purpose, truth, expectation, boundary, or decision clearly.

Present

Provide the reason, evidence, picture, example, or demonstration.

Invite

Allow honest questions, examination, and appropriate disagreement.

Choose

Leave the person responsible for the decision.

Execute

Create an opportunity for the decision to become action.

Observe

Look for evidence in behavior—not merely verbal agreement.

Adjust

Keep what helped. Change what did not. Restore the picture when necessary and create the next opportunity.

A Practical Influence Habit

Before trying to persuade someone, pause and ask:

Am I helping this person understand and choose, or am I trying to force the response I want?

Then use four actions:

  1. State the purpose truthfully.

  2. Explain the next useful action.

  3. Invite one honest question or response.

  4. Observe what the person chooses and does.

The evidence is not whether the person pleased you in the conversation.

The evidence is whether the person understood the choice, acted, and began carrying greater responsibility.

The Biblical Foundation: Truth Permits a Choice

Scripture repeatedly presents people with truth, responsibility, and a choice.

In Joshua 24:15, Joshua called the people to choose whom they would serve. He stated his own commitment clearly:

“As for me and my house, we will serve the Lord.”

Joshua did not hide the decision.

He did not lower the importance of the choice.

He called for a response.

In Mark 10:17–22, Jesus spoke with the rich young ruler, identified what stood between the man and faithful action, and invited him to follow.

The man went away sorrowful.

Jesus did not change the truth to secure agreement.

He did not force the man to follow.

The invitation was real, and so was the man’s responsibility to choose.

This is not a promise that clear truth will always produce the response we want.

It is a picture of influence that preserves responsibility.

We speak truthfully.

We serve.

We invite.

We may establish boundaries and consequences within the authority we have been given.

But we do not own another person’s decision.

What My Experience Taught Me

My responsibility as a coach was never limited to telling players what to do.

I needed to give them a picture.

I needed to explain why the work mattered.

I needed to create an environment where they could learn, practice, question, and improve.

I needed to recognize good work and correct conduct that hurt the player or team.

I also needed to understand where my responsibility ended.

I could influence a player.

I could not choose for the player.

That understanding changed the goal.

The goal was not to produce players who obeyed only while I was present.

The goal was to develop players who could recognize what mattered, make responsible choices, execute, evaluate themselves, and help the people around them.

That is influence without control.

The Next Faithful Action

Identify one person you are trying to influence.

Ask yourself:

  • Have I listened before deciding what this person needs?

  • Is my purpose truthful?

  • Have I made the expectation clear?

  • Have I explained why the action matters?

  • Does the person have the ability and opportunity to act?

  • Have I invited honest questions?

  • Am I respecting the person’s responsibility to choose?

  • Am I prepared to apply appropriate consequences without humiliation?

  • Am I evaluating behavior or merely looking for agreement?

  • What part of this situation belongs to me?

  • What part belongs to the other person?

Then take one action that improves the opportunity for a responsible choice.

Do your part faithfully.

Allow the person to own theirs.

Reflection Questions

  1. Do I sometimes confuse authority with control?

  2. Am I trying to develop ownership or merely immediate compliance?

  3. Do I explain why an expectation matters?

  4. Can people question my ideas respectfully?

  5. Do I use truthful reasons, or do I rely on fear and pressure?

  6. Have I made the desired action clear and possible?

  7. Do I recognize verbal agreement as if it were execution?

  8. Am I carrying responsibility that belongs to another person?

  9. Am I avoiding a necessary boundary because I want to appear supportive?

  10. What will show that the person is beginning to act independently?

Scripture Focus

Joshua 24:15 — Choose whom you will serve.

Supporting Passages

Mark 10:17–22 — Jesus presents truth and permits the rich young ruler to choose.

Deuteronomy 30:19–20 — Life and death are placed before the people with a call to choose life.

Galatians 6:4–5 — Each person examines their own work and carries personal responsibility.

2 Corinthians 4:2 — Truth should be presented openly rather than through deception.

Philemon 8–14 — Paul appeals rather than compelling, seeking a willing response.

James 1:22 — Hearing must become action.

Evidence and Supporting Research

Ryan, R. M., and Deci, E. L. (2000). Self-Determination Theory and the Facilitation of Intrinsic Motivation, Social Development, and Well-Being. American Psychologist, 55(1), 68–78.

Deci, E. L., and Ryan, R. M. (2000). The “What” and “Why” of Goal Pursuits: Human Needs and the Self-Determination of Behavior. Psychological Inquiry, 11(4), 227–268.

Cheon, S. H., Reeve, J., Lee, Y., and Lee, J. (2018). Why Autonomy-Supportive Interventions Work: Explaining the Professional Development of Teachers’ Motivating Style. Teaching and Teacher Education, 69, 43–51.

Reeve, J., et al. (2015). Giving and Receiving Autonomy Support in a High-Stakes Sport Context: A Field-Based Experiment During the 2012 London Paralympic Games. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 19, 59–69.

Carnegie, D. The Golden Book: Principles from How to Win Friends and Influence People.

Final Thought

Influence does not give us ownership of another person.

It gives us responsibility for how we teach, speak, lead, serve, correct, encourage, and create opportunities.

We can provide the picture.

We can explain the purpose.

We can establish the standard.

We can design the environment.

We can recognize progress.

We can apply consequences.

We can offer another opportunity.

Then the other person must choose.

THE COACH OWNS THE INFLUENCE.

THE PLAYER OWNS THE CHOICE.

RESPONSIBLE INFLUENCE HELPS PEOPLE LEARN TO CHOOSE WHEN THE COACH IS NO LONGER PRESENT.


Description

Coaches, teachers, parents, and leaders can shape understanding, opportunity, environment, and probability—but they cannot own another person’s decision. This article explains how truthful persuasion, clear standards, appropriate consequences, and increasing responsibility can help people move from compliance toward genuine ownership.

Tags

World Championship Habits, Influence Without Control, Responsible Leadership, Coaching Education, Player Development, Self-Direction, Personal Responsibility, Athlete Development, Christian Leadership, Teaching and Learning


© 2026 Keith F. McAdams. All Rights Reserved.

World Championship Habits

For Google Blogger, use the article title in the Title field and paste the article body into Compose mode. The description and tags are included at the bottom for easy access; they can be placed in Blogger's Search Description and Labels fields rather than displayed in the article itself.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

THE FUTURE VISION THAT MADE SEFA TAKAR A CAPTAIN

Devotional: God's Word Never Returns Empty

A COACHING PROFILE SHOULD DO MORE THAN GIVE YOU A SCORE