FROM COACH-DIRECTED LEARNING TO SELF-COACHING
FROM COACH-DIRECTED LEARNING TO SELF-COACHING
The Goal Is Not to Create Players Who Need More Coaching. It Is to Create Players Who Can Coach Themselves.
HOW TO LEARN, TEACH, AND INFLUENCE PEOPLE
WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP HABITS
By Keith F. McAdams
There is a point in teaching when helping too much begins to hurt learning.
Early in the learning process, people need direction.
They need structure.
They need explanations.
They need demonstrations.
They need feedback.
They need somebody who can see what they cannot yet see.
But that cannot remain the relationship forever.
Eventually, the learner has to recognize the problem.
The learner has to make the decision.
The learner has to evaluate the result.
The learner has to make the correction.
That is the transition from coach-directed learning to self-coaching.
And it is one of the most important transitions in learning.
THE COACH CANNOT PLAY THE GAME
This is obvious in sports.
A coach can prepare a player.
A coach can teach a system.
A coach can design practice.
A coach can identify mistakes.
A coach can ask questions.
A coach can provide feedback.
But when the game begins, the coach cannot make every decision for the player.
The player has to see what is happening and respond.
That was always important in my coaching.
I wanted structure.
I wanted players to understand exactly what we were trying to accomplish.
But structure was never supposed to eliminate thinking.
It was supposed to prepare players to think.
STRUCTURE FIRST. DECISIONS SECOND.
This connects directly to the previous article.
We do not throw people into complicated decisions before giving them enough structure to understand what they are seeing.
We teach.
We demonstrate.
We practice.
We correct.
We repeat when repetition serves a purpose.
Then we begin transferring responsibility.
That progression matters.
If we transfer responsibility too early, we can create confusion.
If we transfer it too late, we can create dependence.
Good teaching has to recognize the difference.
THE POWER OF THREE
One method I have used throughout my coaching is what I call the Power of Three.
Instead of expecting players to consciously process everything at once, we can identify a small number of important cues.
Teach the whole system.
Then identify three things that matter right now.
Once those become recognizable and increasingly automatic, we can move forward.
The objective is not for the coach to continue shouting those three things forever.
The objective is for the player eventually to see them without being told.
That changes the question.
Instead of:
“Did the player do what I told him to do?”
we begin asking:
“Can the player recognize what needs to be done without me telling him?”
Those are two very different measurements of learning.
COMPLIANCE IS NOT OWNERSHIP
A player can follow instructions without truly learning.
An employee can follow a checklist.
A student can repeat an answer.
A child can follow a parent's direction.
A player can execute exactly what the coach called from the bench.
That may demonstrate compliance.
It does not necessarily demonstrate ownership.
Ownership begins when the person can recognize the situation and choose the appropriate response without waiting for somebody else to provide the answer.
THE RESPONSIBILITY HAS TO MOVE
The progression can be simple:
COACH RECOGNIZES
COACH EXPLAINS
PLAYER PRACTICES
PLAYER RECOGNIZES
PLAYER DECIDES
PLAYER EXECUTES
PLAYER EVALUATES
PLAYER ADJUSTS
Eventually:
PLAYER HELPS SOMEONE ELSE
That final step matters.
One of the strongest indications that someone understands something is the ability to explain it, demonstrate it, or help another person understand it.
The learner begins becoming a teacher.
STOP PROVIDING EVERY ANSWER
This can be difficult for coaches.
It can also be difficult for parents, teachers, managers, and leaders.
We see the problem.
We know the answer.
Giving the answer is faster.
But faster is not always better for learning.
Sometimes the better question is:
What did you see?
Then:
What were your options?
Then:
What did you choose?
Then:
What happened?
Then:
What would you do differently next time?
Now the learner has to participate in the evaluation.
The teacher is no longer doing all the thinking.
FEEDBACK STILL MATTERS
Self-coaching does not mean coaching disappears.
It means the role of the coach changes.
Earlier in the process, feedback may be direct:
“Here is what happened. Here is what needs to change.”
Later, the coach may ask:
“What happened?”
If the player recognizes it correctly, there may be very little to add.
That is progress.
The goal is not silence from the coach.
The goal is better judgment from the learner.
NOTICE → EVALUATE → ADJUST
In an earlier article, we used:
NOTICE → ADJUST → CONTINUE
That remains important.
Self-coaching adds another level of responsibility:
NOTICE → EVALUATE → ADJUST → TRY AGAIN
The learner is increasingly responsible for identifying both the problem and the next action.
This is where reflection becomes useful.
Not endless reflection.
Not paralysis by analysis.
Enough reflection to improve the next attempt.
TWO SCORECARDS
World Championship Habits separates two things that are often confused:
PROCESS
and
RESULTS.
A result tells us what happened.
The process helps us understand why.
A player may get a good result from a poor decision.
A player may make the correct decision and still get a poor result.
If we only evaluate outcomes, we can teach the wrong lesson.
Self-coaching requires learning to evaluate both.
What did I do?
Why did I do it?
What happened?
Was the decision sound?
What should I repeat or change?
That is a much stronger learning process than simply asking:
Did I succeed or fail?
PERFORMANCE MUST PRODUCE INFORMATION
This creates another World Championship Habits progression:
PERFORMANCE
CAPTURE
MEASURE
MAKE IT EVIDENT
IDENTIFY THE OPPORTUNITY
CHOOSE THE NEXT STEP
PRACTICE
PERFORM AGAIN
PRODUCE NEW PROOF
Performance is not simply the end of learning.
Performance gives us information for the next cycle of learning.
That is why a mistake does not automatically mean the learning process failed.
A mistake can provide the information necessary for the next correction.
THE COACH SHOULD BECOME LESS NECESSARY
This can sound strange in coaching.
But I believe one measure of good coaching is whether players become progressively less dependent on the coach.
They should still value coaching.
They should still seek feedback.
They should still be teachable.
But they should become increasingly capable of recognizing, deciding, evaluating, and correcting for themselves.
If every problem requires the coach to provide the answer, responsibility never really transferred.
THIS GOES FAR BEYOND SPORTS
The same principle applies to parenting.
Teaching.
Leadership.
Business.
Mentoring.
Relationships.
If we always solve the problem for another person, we may solve today's problem while doing very little to prepare that person for tomorrow's problem.
The better question becomes:
What does this person need from me right now to eventually do this without me?
Sometimes the answer is instruction.
Sometimes demonstration.
Sometimes practice.
Sometimes feedback.
Sometimes a question.
And sometimes the best thing we can do is stop talking and give the person an opportunity to decide.
WHAT THE RESEARCH SUPPORTS
Research on learning and metacognition supports the importance of learners becoming capable of monitoring and regulating their own learning.
Metacognition involves thinking about and evaluating one's own thinking and learning.
Self-regulated learning extends that responsibility into planning, monitoring performance, evaluating results, and adjusting future behavior.
Research also supports the importance of retrieval, feedback, varied practice, and opportunities to apply learning rather than simply receiving information repeatedly.
That does not mean research proves one universal coaching method.
It supports the broader principle:
Durable learning requires increasing participation by the learner.
The learner cannot remain a passive recipient of instruction forever.
THE BIBLICAL PATTERN
Jesus provides an extraordinary example of progressively transferring responsibility.
He taught His disciples.
They watched Him.
They listened.
They asked questions.
He corrected them.
But He did not keep them permanently beside Him simply listening.
Luke 9 describes Jesus sending the twelve out.
They had to go.
They had to act.
They had to apply what they had learned.
Then they returned and reported what they had done.
That sequence matters.
TEACH
PREPARE
SEND
EXPERIENCE
RETURN
REFLECT
Teaching was preparing them for responsibility.
WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP HABITS APPLICATION
Ask yourself:
Am I teaching this person—or creating dependence on me?
Then ask:
What responsibility can I transfer next?
Do not transfer everything at once.
Transfer the next appropriate responsibility.
Maybe today the learner recognizes the problem.
Tomorrow the learner chooses the solution.
Later the learner evaluates the result.
Eventually the learner adjusts independently.
And ultimately, the learner may be able to help someone else.
THE NEXT FAITHFUL ACTION
Choose one person you are currently teaching, coaching, parenting, mentoring, or leading.
Identify one thing you normally tell that person.
The next time the situation occurs, do not immediately provide the answer.
Ask:
“WHAT DO YOU SEE?”
Listen.
Then ask:
“WHAT DO YOU THINK YOU SHOULD DO?”
Now you are not simply correcting behavior.
You are developing judgment.
FINAL THOUGHT
The purpose of teaching is not to demonstrate how much the teacher knows.
It is to help another person learn.
And eventually, genuine learning has to belong to the learner.
The coach provides structure.
The coach creates the environment.
The coach teaches.
The coach observes.
The coach provides feedback.
But gradually, responsibility moves.
FROM BEING TOLD
TO RECOGNIZING
TO DECIDING
TO DOING
TO EVALUATING
TO ADJUSTING
TO HELPING OTHERS.
That is more than following instructions.
That is ownership.
And ownership is one of the clearest signs that teaching has become learning.
EXPERIENCE LESSON
Do not measure your teaching only by whether people follow your instructions.
Measure whether they are becoming capable of recognizing, deciding, evaluating, and adjusting without your instructions.
WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP HABITS PROCESS
Structure → Practice → Recognition → Decision → Execution → Evaluation → Adjustment → Ownership
SCRIPTURE
Luke 9:1–10
Jesus prepared the disciples and then sent them to apply what they had learned. They returned and reported what they had done.
SUPPORTING RESEARCH
Research on meta cognition and self-regulated learning supports teaching learners to monitor, evaluate, and regulate their own learning rather than remaining dependent on external direction.
Research on retrieval practice, feedback, and transfer also supports requiring learners to actively retrieve, apply, evaluate, and adapt knowledge across situations.
These findings support the learning principles discussed here. The specific World Championship Habits applications and coaching interpretations come from my coaching experience and methodology.
SUBSTACK DESCRIPTION
Great teaching cannot end with people waiting to be told what to do. The responsibility must gradually move from the teacher to the learner—from recognizing the problem to making decisions, evaluating results, adjusting, and eventually helping others. The goal is not less learning. It is greater ownership.
© 2026 Keith F. McAdams. World Championship Habits. All rights reserved.
TAGS
World Championship Habits, Learning, Teaching, Self-Coaching, Coaching, Leadership, Ownership, Habits, Player Development, Self-Regulated Learning
Comments
Post a Comment