How to Know Learning Happened : How We Teach | Article 6

 




How to Know Learning Happened

Part Two: How We Teach | Article 6
How to Learn, Teach, and Influence People
By Keith F. McAdams

One technique I use is what I call “Easy to See” proof.

Look at the warm-up.

Are players incorporating the habits we have taught into their routines? Are they using those preparation behaviors themselves, or does the coach still need to prompt every action?

Look at what happens after good execution.

Do players recognize it? Do they give a teammate a high five or offer a few words of encouragement?

I can observe those behaviors while the work continues.

There is no need to stop everything, put someone under pressure, or create a formal test. The daily system already provides opportunities to see whether the teaching is becoming part of what people do.

Evidence of learning should be built into the system. Some of it should be easy to see.

That does not mean one correct action proves permanent learning. It gives me something to observe. Seeing the behavior repeatedly, in appropriate situations and with less prompting, gives me stronger evidence that it is becoming established.

The question is whether I have organized the teaching so that those opportunities exist.

I can explain a responsibility, demonstrate it, and give players an opportunity to practice.

That tells me what I taught.

It does not yet tell me what they learned.

A player may nod during a meeting. A group may complete a drill. Someone may repeat the words I just used.

Those responses provide information, but I still need to examine what the person understands and can use.

Exposure does not equal adoption.

From the teacher’s perspective, that principle creates a responsibility: look for evidence of learning and use what you find to decide how to teach next.

My system begins with a picture of what we are trying to develop.

That picture has a role in evaluation too.

Before teaching, I need to know what I want the player to understand and do. After teaching, we need something specific against which to examine the attempt.

“Prepare properly” is difficult to evaluate until we explain what preparation includes.

If we have taught players to begin and end the warm-up with a deliberate breath, I can watch for those moments. If we have taught a particular movement or posture, I can observe whether it appears in the routine.

The picture makes the expectation clearer for the player and the observation clearer for the coach.

Before teaching a habit, know where it belongs and what its use will look like.

Where will the player practice it?

When will the opportunity appear?

What will I be able to observe?

Those questions help turn an intention into something teachable.

Our warm-up provided one of those opportunities.

We taught preparation as a routine containing specific behaviors. The warm-up gave players repeated opportunities to practice those behaviors before more demanding work began.

It also gave me a relatively straightforward place to observe.

Were the taught actions appearing?

Were players remembering the sequence?

Were they beginning without waiting for another explanation?

If something was missing, I could identify the particular behavior that needed attention.

The observation did not have to become a confrontation. I could give a reminder, clarify the purpose, or provide another demonstration.

The next warm-up gave us another opportunity to look.

That is the practical value of Easy to See. Evaluation can happen naturally within the work.

Celebrating good execution provided another example.

Recognition was part of our education program. We wanted players to notice when teammates did something well and acknowledge it.

A high five made that recognition visible.

Were players doing it themselves?

Did they recognize a good decision, an appropriate attempt, or an improvement?

Were they talking about good performances?

If I had to initiate every celebration, the behavior still depended on me. When players began recognizing good work independently, I could see them taking responsibility for something we had taught.

I also wanted to know what they were recognizing.

A celebration alone does not tell me whether someone understood the play. A few specific words can give us more information.

“You supported him when he was under pressure.”

“You made the adjustment we discussed.”

“You were ready before the puck arrived.”

Now recognition also communicates something about understanding.

The player who recognizes good execution is showing something about what they have learned.

Our principle of keeping eyes on the ice served a related purpose.

Another player’s shift was an opportunity to learn. Watch the situation. Notice what works. Listen to the correction. Carry the useful information into your own performance.

For evaluation, the important question was what happened afterward.

Could the observing player recognize a similar situation on their next shift?

Could they apply the correction without first having to make the same mistake?

Could they explain what they had noticed?

That gave me a way to examine whether observation was becoming usable learning.

The bench routine offered another place to look.

Our national-team work grew partly from video showing problems with readiness, line changes, and attention before players entered the ice.

We taught players to maintain an alert position, breathe, and keep their eyes on the ice. The next five players needed to prepare for the coming change.

We also established a clear movement routine: players entering went over the boards; players leaving came through the door.

These instructions gave us specific things to observe.

Were the next players ready?

Were they following the play?

Did they use the agreed route?

Did they recognize their responsibility as they entered?

A player might explain every step in a meeting and still need reminders on the bench. That would tell me the routine needed more practice in the situation where it was supposed to operate.

When players prepared without waiting for my instruction, that was evidence of increasing independence.

I still needed to observe repeated opportunities. One organized change would not establish that the routine was dependable.

But the evidence was available. We had given the behavior a place in the system.

Another example came from the way I organized instruction around three connected priorities.

I used:

Preview the three. Teach the three. Review the same three.

When checking learning, the review needs participation from the players.

Before repeating the information myself, I can ask them to retrieve it. They can explain the responsibilities, show them on the board, identify them on video, or walk through the positioning.

The sequence becomes:

Preview → Teach → Players retrieve → Clarify → Execute.

If I repeat the three points and everyone listens, I have completed another explanation.

If players retrieve and apply them, I have more information about what they understand.

Their explanation does not need to sound exactly like mine.

During my work in Turkey, numbers helped us organize tactics when my vocabulary was not sufficient to explain everything easily.

The number gave us a shared reference within the playbook. The player still needed to understand what it represented.

Knowing the label was a beginning.

Could the player connect it with the situation, recognize the relevant responsibility, and act?

That was what I needed to examine.

Our organized tryout provided another example.

At one recent youth tryout, we had approximately sixty players and ninety minutes. That was not enough time to develop a complete picture of every player.

An open scrimmage also creates uneven opportunities. Some players receive more passes. Some play beside stronger teammates. A capable player may have few opportunities to show what they can do with the puck.

We gave players three responsibilities to prepare:

  • Line up correctly for defensive-zone faceoffs.

  • Execute their defensive-zone coverage responsibility.

  • Go to the net, with particular attention to the second forward driving the middle lane.

Before the tryout, players received an email with explanations and diagrams. Coaches then met with them in the locker rooms, explained the responsibilities, and drew them on the board.

We gave the instruction a place to appear.

One starting situation was a defensive-zone faceoff. Before dropping the puck, we could observe who recognized where to line up and prepared for the assignment. Once the puck dropped, play became live.

Another starting situation gave the offensive team possession in the zone. Before the whistle, the defensive players could recognize the situation and move into coverage. On the whistle, play became live.

The middle-lane drive was something we watched for as offensive rushes developed naturally. It was not a third organized starting situation.

We organized the starting conditions. The players still had to read and respond to what happened next.

That gave us information about recall, positioning, communication, decisions, and attempts to execute the instruction.

A player could demonstrate something useful without scoring a goal.

This was not a pass-or-fail system test. Missing an assignment did not automatically eliminate someone. Players arrived with different experiences, and returning players already knew more of our system.

We were gathering another part of the picture: what did this player recognize and attempt after receiving instruction?

The tryout could show an initial response. Continued practices would be needed to examine what the player retained and developed.

My power-play work provided a way to observe learning as the demands increased.

In our “Minute Man” work, we began with five players and no defenders. We rehearsed options, worked from both sides, and repeated passing and shooting actions.

We later added defenders and created conditions in which players had to choose among the options. The work also included a timed competition.

Each condition gave us something different to observe.

Without defenders, we could examine the sequence and execution. With defenders, we could examine whether players recognized what was available. Under a time limit, we could observe how they managed the opportunity with another demand added.

Could they perform the action?

Could they identify when to use it?

Could they make the decision and execute while the situation changed?

The evaluation developed with the teaching.

A player may complete a rehearsed sequence because they know where the puck is going and what happens next. That is useful practice.

But a game adds choices.

An opponent takes away the expected pass. A teammate arrives late. Space opens somewhere else.

Now the player must recognize the situation and decide what to do.

A successful repetition gives me evidence. A changed situation gives me another question to examine.

That is why I need to distinguish understanding from execution.

A player can identify the appropriate pass and still miss it. Someone may understand where to move but arrive late because their skating needs development.

If I treat every unsuccessful result as a failure to understand, I may give another explanation when the player needs skill practice.

If I assume understanding because someone has strong physical skills, I may overlook a decision-making problem.

I need to ask what happened.

What did the player see?

What were they trying to do?

Was the choice appropriate?

What prevented execution?

The answers help me choose the next response.

The same distinction applies beyond hockey. A student may understand a mathematical method but make an arithmetic error. An employee may understand a procedure but need more practice using the equipment.

A useful evaluation identifies the difficulty clearly enough to guide the teaching.

The amount of assistance also matters.

If I call out every movement, I may be helping the player complete the task. But I have less evidence about what they can recognize independently.

Guidance has a place. I also need to create appropriate opportunities to perform with less of it.

Can the person begin?

Can they identify a problem?

Can they make an adjustment?

Can they recognize when they need help?

Independence includes asking a useful question.

This connects with the attention tools discussed in Part One.

I could remind a player to return their eyes to the ice. I could ask whether their mind had drifted.

When a player independently noticed the drift and used AID—Awareness, Interrupt, Direct—I could observe them taking more responsibility.

That was different from reciting what the letters meant.

Time matters too.

A person may perform something immediately after an explanation because the instructions are still fresh. I also want to know what remains available later.

Can they return at the next practice and recognize the responsibility?

Can they explain the idea after closing the notes?

Can they apply it when the task is presented differently?

Research helps clarify why these questions matter.

Nicholas Soderstrom and Robert Bjork’s review distinguishes performance during practice from more lasting learning. What looks smooth during instruction may not reliably indicate later retention or transfer. Their review supports examining what learners can do after a delay and under changed conditions, rather than relying only on immediate practice results. Soderstrom and Bjork, 2015

For a coach, that means keeping today’s observation in perspective. It provides evidence about today’s performance. Later opportunities help us examine what has been retained and what can be used elsewhere.

Checking learning can also contribute to learning.

Jeffrey Karpicke and Janell Blunt found that retrieval practice supported learning from science texts, including performance on questions requiring understanding and inference. Their study supports asking learners to retrieve information actively rather than relying entirely on repeated exposure. It does not establish that recalling an explanation alone demonstrates mastery of a physical skill. Karpicke and Blunt, 2011

These findings support aspects of the approach. They do not validate every routine in my system. My responsibility is to observe carefully, consider the conditions, and adjust.

The way I respond to the evidence matters.

If admitting confusion leads to embarrassment, the learner has a reason to hide it. That gives me a less accurate picture.

My standards of focus and effort remain in place. Within those standards, an honest learning mistake gives us something to address.

I want players willing to tell me what they did not understand.

I also need to be willing to discover that my explanation was unclear.

An evaluation of learning also gives me information about my teaching.

Did I explain the task clearly?

Did I demonstrate what mattered?

Did the person have enough appropriate practice?

Did I expect independence before preparing them for it?

Did the activity give them a fair opportunity to show what I was trying to observe?

Those questions keep the coach inside the learning process.

My faith shapes how I understand the responsibility to apply learning.

Philippians 4:9 calls readers to put into practice what they have learned, received, heard, and seen. I see a connection with the purpose of teaching: helping learning enter daily conduct. This is a spiritual foundation for my approach, rather than a scientific measure of learning. Philippians 4:8–9

The three patterns running through this book help organize the teacher’s responsibility.

Environment: Build opportunities to observe into warm-ups, meetings, routines, practice, and games. Make expectations clear and create conditions where learners can ask questions and reveal what they understand.

Mastery: Examine understanding, execution, retention, and self-correction. Recognize progress and identify what still needs teaching or practice.

Compete: Give learners appropriate opportunities to use their preparation under real demands. Observe how they recognize situations, make choices, and act with increasing independence.

For World Championship Habits, Easy to See begins with a clear connection between the teaching and the behavior.

What did we teach?

Where should it appear?

What does it look like?

Is it happening with less prompting?

Does it continue over time?

What should we teach next?

These questions do not require a complicated assessment system. Often, they require the coach to know what to look for and pay attention.

The warm-up can reveal whether preparation habits are entering the routine.

A high five can reveal that a player noticed good execution.

A board explanation can reveal what an assignment means to the player.

A line change can reveal readiness and coordination.

An organized scrimmage can reveal an attempt to apply instruction.

A changed power-play situation can reveal whether players recognize an available option.

Each gives us part of the picture.

Make the expectation clear. Give it a place in the system. Watch what happens. Recognize progress and teach the next step.

That is Easy to See.

© 2026 Keith F. McAdams. All rights reserved.

Tags: Teaching, Learning, Coaching, Easy to See, Feedback, Assessment, Player Development, Habits, World Championship Habits

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

THE FUTURE VISION THAT MADE SEFA TAKAR A CAPTAIN

Devotional: God's Word Never Returns Empty

A COACHING PROFILE SHOULD DO MORE THAN GIVE YOU A SCORE