When a Coach Is Struggling, Doing Nothing Is Not an Option
When a Coach Is Struggling, Doing Nothing Is Not an Option
Five ways a Director of Coaching can address a coaching problem before it becomes an organizational problem
By Keith F. McAdams
World Championship Habits
When I was a national coach and Director of Coaching, part of my responsibility was developing coaches.
I worked with coaches from different organizations and federations. Coaches were regularly sent to us for development, and we also ran a coaching-development program.
But there was a problem I thought about often.
There were never enough resources.
I was the national coach, but I was also the Director of Coaching. I had responsibility for developing coaches and working with the federations while still having my own responsibilities as a national coach.
There were only so many hours in a day.
When a coach was struggling, there wasn't always another person I could send in.
There wasn't a mentor available for every coach.
There wasn't an outside coaching-development specialist waiting to intervene.
There wasn't always another qualified coach available who could solve a particular problem.
Many times, I had to work directly with the coach myself.
I often thought about how difficult that made the job.
You could identify a coaching problem.
You could know that the coach needed help.
You could understand what needed to change.
But who was going to do it?
That experience eventually became another piece of the puzzle in how I think about coach development today.
A Director of Coaching should not have only one possible response when a coach is struggling.
I believe there are five basic ways to address the problem.
These are not five steps.
They do not have to happen in order.
You don't necessarily use all five.
Any one of them might solve the problem.
The important thing is that someone acts.
Because particularly in youth hockey, doing nothing may be the most damaging decision of all.
1. Direct Accountability
Sometimes the coach doesn't need an elaborate development program.
The coach needs accountability.
Have the coach report directly to the Director of Coaching every week.
What happened this week?
What went well?
What went wrong?
What problem are you trying to correct?
What are you going to do differently?
Then come back the following week and talk about it again.
This creates accountability, but it does something else.
It creates an opportunity to educate.
Instead of discovering three months later that the same problem has continued, the Director of Coaching can address it while it is happening.
Sometimes that may be enough to change the direction of the coach.
2. Find the Coach a Mentor
The second possibility is mentorship.
A coach may recognize that something isn't working but not know how to fix it.
Find somebody who does.
The mentor can observe, listen, ask questions, share experience, and help the coach work through the specific problem.
The mentor doesn't take over the team.
The objective is to help the coach become better equipped to lead the team.
Research provides support for the value of coach development, although the results are not universal.
One controlled study involving a formal mentoring program found improvements in coaches' own perceptions of aspects of their communication and coach-athlete relationships, although the athletes did not report corresponding improvements in all measures.
That distinction is important.
Mentorship can help, but simply assigning a mentor doesn't guarantee change.
If an organization doesn't have the appropriate mentor internally, World Championship Habits can provide another option by working directly with the coach while keeping the Director of Coaching involved.
3. Intervene and Solve the Problem
Sometimes mentorship isn't what is needed.
The problem needs to be attacked directly.
Identify the problem.
Talk with the Director of Coaching.
Talk with the coach.
Determine what can be changed.
Develop a plan.
Then go to work on the problem.
Research gives us reason to believe focused coach-development interventions can make a difference.
A systematic review and meta-analysis of interpersonal development programs for sport coaches and parents found significant improvements in some youth-athlete outcomes, including motivational climate, enjoyment, and anxiety.
Another youth-sport intervention combined theoretical education, individual consultation, and video analysis. Researchers reported positive changes in areas of the coach-athlete relationship, including communication, cooperation, encouragement, connection, and trust.
That doesn't mean every intervention works.
It means intervention gives us an opportunity to change something.
This is the idea behind the World Championship Habits Rapid Coaching Intervention.
It isn't designed to force a coach through an entire generic coaching program when one specific problem needs attention.
Start with the problem.
Maybe it is practice organization.
Maybe it is communication.
Maybe it is dealing with parents.
Maybe it is player development.
Maybe it is team culture.
Maybe it is bench management.
Maybe it is teaching.
Maybe it is accountability.
Maybe it is systems.
Find the problem.
Then build the intervention around the problem.
4. Add an Assistant Coach Who Can Solve the Problem
Sometimes you have the right head coach, but the coach has a weakness.
That doesn't necessarily mean you need another head coach.
You may need another strength on the coaching staff.
If the head coach is strong at developing relationships but weak with systems, find an assistant who understands systems.
If the coach understands hockey but struggles with practice organization, find somebody who excels at planning and running practices.
If communication is the weakness, bring in somebody who communicates well.
Nobody is great at everything.
The question shouldn't always be:
Do we need to replace this coach?
Sometimes the better question is:
What is this coaching staff missing?
Build the staff so that one coach's strengths can help compensate for another coach's weaknesses.
The right assistant coach may solve the problem.
5. Replace the Coach
There is also a fifth option.
Sometimes the coach cannot—or will not—make the necessary changes.
At that point, the Director of Coaching has another responsibility.
You have a responsibility to the coach.
But you also have a responsibility to the players, parents, other coaches, and the organization.
There comes a point when keeping someone in the wrong position isn't helping the organization.
It may not even be helping the coach.
Sometimes the solution is to make a coaching change.
The Biggest Mistake: Doing Nothing
There is another choice.
Do nothing.
In youth hockey, I believe this can be one of the biggest mistakes a Director of Coaching makes.
Parents have invested significant money in their child's hockey season.
But it isn't only money.
They have invested time.
Travel.
Hotels.
Weekends.
Early mornings.
And a tremendous amount of emotional energy in their children.
When parents believe there is a serious coaching problem, those concerns don't necessarily stay between one parent and the coach.
One parent talks to another.
That parent talks to another.
Another parent has experienced something similar.
Very quickly, what started as one concern can become a much larger problem.
Now you aren't simply dealing with a coach who needs help.
You may be dealing with parents who have lost confidence in the coach.
Players can become affected.
The atmosphere surrounding the team can change.
Eventually, confidence in the organization itself can be damaged.
That downward spiral is something I have seen in hockey.
Research supports the broader importance of communication.
A study involving 6,641 parents of youth athletes found that 29.4 percent reported feeling a lack of communication with their child's coach. The researchers emphasized the importance of appropriate parent-coach communication in creating better circumstances for young athletes.
Research into youth sport also shows that coaches and parents are both important parts of the environment surrounding the young athlete. Communication, expectations, and relationships among those adults matter.
That research doesn't prove that every parent complaint will spread from one parent to another.
That part comes from my experience.
But it reinforces why communication and coaching problems cannot simply be ignored.
That is why I believe coaching problems should be addressed immediately.
Immediate action does not mean immediately firing the coach.
That is important.
Immediate action means:
Acknowledge the problem.
Understand the problem.
Choose an appropriate way to address the problem.
Maybe direct accountability solves it.
Maybe mentorship solves it.
Maybe intervention solves it.
Maybe adding the right assistant solves it.
Maybe eventually you determine that the coach needs to be replaced.
Any one of those may be the answer.
Doing nothing isn't an answer.
What I Would Have Wanted as a Director of Coaching
When I look back at my own experience, this is the part that stands out.
I didn't have all of these resources.
A large part of my job was developing coaches.
But I was also coaching.
I was working with federations.
I was running coach-development programs.
And when coaches needed help, much of that responsibility came directly back to me.
Today, I see those experiences differently.
They helped me recognize that a Director of Coaching shouldn't have to personally solve every coaching problem.
The Director needs options.
Sometimes the Director should work directly with the coach.
Sometimes another mentor is the better answer.
Sometimes somebody needs to come in, identify the problem, build a plan, and help the coach execute it.
That is one of the reasons World Championship Habits now offers mentorship and Rapid Coaching Intervention.
It provides two more resources that I often wished I had available when I was responsible for developing coaches myself.
The Principle
A struggling coach doesn't automatically need to be fired.
A struggling coach needs the problem addressed.
Hold the coach accountable.
Find a mentor.
Intervene.
Strengthen the staff.
Or, when necessary, make a change.
The method depends on the problem.
But the responsibility doesn't change.
When you are responsible for developing coaches, identifying the problem is only the beginning.
Leadership requires deciding what you are going to do about it.
A struggling coach doesn't always need to be replaced.
But a struggling coach should never be ignored.
World Championship Habits
Develop the Coach. Develop the Player. Strengthen the Program.
© 2026 Keith F. McAdams. All Rights Reserved.
Tags
#WorldChampionshipHabits #CoachDevelopment #HockeyCoaching #Leadership #Mentorship #HockeyDevelopment #CoachingEducation #YouthHockey #HockeyDirector #CoachMentoring
Comments
Post a Comment