Power Questions: Questions Unlock the Next Performance: How We Teach | Article 12





Ask Better Questions Before Giving More Answers

Part Two: How We Teach | Article 12

How to Learn, Teach, and Influence People

By Keith F. McAdams

A question can help unlock the next performance, but only when it is connected to what the player must see, understand, and execute.

My coaching philosophy is built around Power Questions. This does not mean asking questions constantly or using questions to avoid teaching. It means asking questions that help players recognize the situation, understand their responsibility, choose the correct tactic, and improve the next performance.

The central question is:

What did the player see, and what does the player need to recognize before making the next decision?

Vision Comes First

A question is not useful if the player did not see the play.

The coach may see one angle. The player may see another. A teammate may see something different again. Video can provide valuable evidence, but it cannot reproduce exactly what the player saw in real time.

That is why one of my most important questions is:

“What did you see on that play?”

The answer tells me what the player recognized before I evaluate the decision.

Sometimes the player saw the situation differently from me. I do not argue simply to prove that I am right. I may ask:

  • What else could you have seen?

  • Where was the open space?

  • Who had the puck?

  • Who was your responsibility?

  • What changed before you made the decision?

The player must first learn to discipline his eyes.

In hockey, the player must learn to identify:

  • Who has the puck?

  • Who is on offense?

  • Who is on defense?

  • What are the numbers?

  • Where is the open space?

  • Who is going to get the loose puck?

  • Where is the passing lane?

  • Where is the defender’s stick?

  • Where is the goalie looking?

  • What is the gap?

  • What is the situation?

Many mistakes begin with tunnel vision.

A player may work hard while backchecking through the middle but look only straight ahead. He does not scan right, left, or behind him, so he fails to find the player he must cover.

I might ask:

“Did you see a player to pick up?”

If the player says no, the question has revealed the problem. He was working hard, but he was not scanning.

The teaching sequence becomes simple:

Look toward the goal. Scan right. Scan left. Check behind you. Find your man. Backcheck to the goalpost.

Questions Must Connect to the System

Power Questions should come from the system, terminology, playing rules, and responsibilities the team has already learned.

Terminology organizes the game. It helps players understand where they are in the system.

For example, a power-play system may be organized around:

Breakout → Entry → Possession → Setup

The four terms describe the stages of the system. They are not four unrelated words.

A power play may begin with a controlled breakout when the team has time and no pressure. It may also begin with an offensive-zone faceoff, where the team must first gain possession and then set up.

The sequence helps players understand what must happen next.

A defensive rush may be organized around:

Read → Communicate → Pressure Up or Contain

The player must read the situation first. Then he communicates with his teammates. After that, the team pressures up or contains according to the numbers and the situation.

Questions should help players use the terminology:

  • What part of the sequence are we in?

  • Did we gain possession?

  • Were we ready to set up?

  • What did the numbers tell us?

  • Should we pressure up or contain?

  • What responsibility did you have?

Playing Rules Are Different

Playing rules are not the same as terminology.

Terminology organizes the system. Playing rules guide players during the game and practice.

Examples of playing rules include:

  • Get every loose puck.

  • Make the easy pass.

  • Shoot on the hard pass.

  • Never go offsides.

  • Pressure up in even situations.

  • Pressure up when we have an advantage.

  • F3 supports the offense, tracks, or backchecks.

Some playing rules are simple because the player does not need to calculate much.

If there is a loose puck and you are closest to it, get it.

If the puck is on a hard pass, shoot it.

If an easy pass is available, make the easy pass.

If you are entering the offensive zone, never go offsides.

The coach can use questions to confirm whether the player recognized the rule:

  • Was there a loose puck?

  • Were you the closest player?

  • Was the easy pass available?

  • Was the pass hard enough to shoot?

  • Where was the puck when you crossed the blue line?

  • What was F3’s responsibility?

The question supports the playing rule. It does not become a random interrogation.

Questions Help Players Understand Why

Players should understand why a playing rule exists.

Why do we want players to make the easy pass?

Because it allows the team to play quicker and helps maintain possession.

Why do we want players to shoot on the hard pass?

Because an extra touch may slow the play or create a turnover.

Why do we want players to get every loose puck?

Because possession gives the team another opportunity to attack and prevents the opposition from gaining the puck.

Why must players never go offsides?

Because going offsides stops the offensive rush and creates a problem for the entire team.

The coach may explain the reason first. Then the question helps the player recognize the rule during the next performance.

Power Questions Move in Two Directions

Coaches ask questions of players, but players also ask questions of coaches, teammates, and themselves.

Growth should move in both directions.

The coach must be willing to learn what the player saw. The player must learn to examine what he saw and how he responded.

A player may ask:

  • What should I look for in that situation?

  • Why was that pass the best option?

  • What was my responsibility?

  • What should I do when the first option is not available?

  • How can I recognize the pressure earlier?

These questions show that the player is beginning to take responsibility for learning.

The coach still teaches the system. The player must learn to read the situation and execute within it.

The Coach Must Choose the Right Moment

I do not interrupt the flow of the game to conduct a lesson.

The game is going to happen. If possible, I ask a question immediately afterward, while the player can still remember the play. Even then, a player may forget what happened only a few seconds later.

Questions must be timed correctly and directed to the right person.

Hockey is emotional. Some players will not receive a question well immediately after a mistake. Sometimes the coach must stabilize the situation first and ask the question later.

A question should not create blame.

If a line or group of five players is discussing a mistake on the bench, I may ask the group what happened rather than single out the player involved. The players can help one another identify the adjustment.

Useful questions include:

  • What went right?

  • What went wrong?

  • What was important at that moment?

  • What did we need from one another?

  • What is the next best play?

When there is good chemistry, the conversation can focus on the play instead of the person.

The goal is not to prove who was wrong. The goal is to find the next solution.

Questions Can Change the Practice

Most questions during practice are simple.

A player may not understand the drill, the terminology, the sequence, or his responsibility. If the entire team cannot follow the drill at the board, I change the drill or simplify the explanation. We can return to it later.

That is not a failure of the system. It is feedback about the teaching at that moment.

During the 2025–26 season, Cody Horner, a talented offensive player for the Tampa Bay Hockey Club, asked why he could not remain in a 1-3-1 power-play position.

He was free to move into that position at any time during the game. However, the team first had to gain possession before the power-play setup could work.

I allowed him to try it. The experiment showed that the formation was ineffective because we were not gaining possession and the other team kept clearing the puck.

The coach listens, explains the tactical constraint, and may test the player’s idea. The game supplies the evidence.

Offensive and Defensive Vision Reinforce Each Other

A good defensive player sees open players, passing lanes, and the lanes that must be closed. That same vision can help him become a better passer.

A strong offensive player already sees open lanes and available options. He should be able to apply that vision defensively by recognizing which lanes the opponent wants to use and taking them away.

This is especially useful when developing gifted offensive players.

Rather than treating defense as unrelated work, I connect defense to a strength they already possess:

“You know how to find open passing lanes? Now use that same vision to recognize which lanes the opponent wants to use and close them.”

In my coaching philosophy, offensive and defensive vision reinforce each other. This is based on my coaching experience. It does not mean every player will automatically transfer one skill to the other.

Questions Must Lead to Action

A question should help the player improve the next performance.

After the player explains what he saw, the coach may help him identify the responsibility and the next action:

See → Understand → Choose → Execute

For example:

  • What did you see?

  • What was your responsibility?

  • What options were available?

  • Which option best followed the playing rule?

  • What will you do next time?

The final question is important:

“What is the next best play?”

The purpose of reflection is not to keep the player trapped in the previous mistake. The purpose is to prepare him for the next opportunity.

What My Experience Taught Me

My experience taught me that questions are most useful when they are connected to vision, terminology, playing rules, and action.

A question should help the player see the situation more clearly, understand the responsibility, and make the next correct decision.

The coach must teach first. The coach must not use questions to avoid giving necessary information.

The player must eventually become able to ask himself the question and recognize the answer while the game is happening.

World Championship Habits Application

Use this process when coaching or teaching:

  1. Teach the system and the terminology.

  2. Establish the playing rule.

  3. Ask what the learner saw.

  4. Identify the responsibility.

  5. Connect the responsibility to the available choices.

  6. Ask for the next best action.

  7. Observe the next performance.

  8. Reflect and adjust.

The process is:

See → Understand → Choose → Execute → Reflect → Adjust

Environment, Mastery, and Compete

Environment: The coach creates an organized environment with clear terminology, playing rules, and responsibilities.

Mastery: The player repeatedly practices seeing the situation, understanding the responsibility, and making the correct choice.

Compete: The player must use the process under pressure, when time and space are limited and the situation is changing.

Application Beyond Hockey

A teacher can ask, “What did you notice in the problem?”

A supervisor can ask, “What information did you use before making that decision?”

A parent can ask, “What happened, and what could you do differently next time?”

A student can ask, “What do I understand, what do I need to review, and what is my next action?”

The questions will change, but the structure remains:

Vision creates understanding. Understanding supports the decision. The decision produces execution. Reflection prepares the next performance.

Next Action and Reflection

  • What must the learner see before making the decision?

  • What terminology organizes the situation?

  • What playing rule applies?

  • What responsibility belongs to the learner?

  • What question will help the learner recognize the next action?

  • Is this the right moment to ask?

  • What evidence will show whether the next performance improved?

Scripture Focus

“Let all things be done decently and in order.”

— 1 Corinthians 14:40

“A word fitly spoken is like apples of gold in a setting of silver.”

— Proverbs 25:11

These passages support order, timing, and purposeful communication. They do not prove that every coaching question will improve performance. They provide a biblical foundation for teaching with order, wisdom, and care.

Evidence and Supporting Research

Research on coaching decision-making supports the use of representative practice and reflection that connects questions to the demands of the sport. This supports the need to choose questions carefully and connect them to the actual situation.

Research on learning from errors suggests that guided self-explanation can help learners understand mistakes and perform better on similar future problems. This supports questions that help a player explain what he saw and identify what he will do next.

Research on visual search supports the importance of recognizing relevant information in complex sport environments. Players must learn where and when to look.

These studies support the principles behind this article. They do not prove that my exact Power Questions method will work in every environment.

My claim is narrower: in my coaching experience, questions worked best when they were connected to a playing rule, asked at the right time, and directed toward what the player actually saw.

Supporting sources:

  • Ashford, M., Copec, E., Abraham, A., and Poolton, J. “Coaching Player Decision Making in Rugby Union.” Journal of Sports Sciences

  • Richey, J. E., and Nokes-Malach, T. J. “Effects of Self-Explaining Feedback on Learning from Problem-Solving Errors.” Contemporary Educational Psychology

  • Wang, Q., Guo, W., Gao, D., et al. “Differences in Visual Search Behavior Between Expert and Novice Athletes.” Frontiers in Physiology


Tags: Coaching, Player Development, Power Questions, Sports Teaching, Decision Making, Vision Training, Hockey, Leadership, Learning, Performance

Copyright © 2026 Keith F. McAdams. All rights reserved.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

THE FUTURE VISION THAT MADE SEFA TAKAR A CAPTAIN

Devotional: God's Word Never Returns Empty

A COACHING PROFILE SHOULD DO MORE THAN GIVE YOU A SCORE