Wisdom in Using Knowledge: Knowing what to use, when to use it, and when to stop talking
Wisdom in Using Knowledge
Knowing what to use, when to use it, and when to stop talking
Part Three — How We Influence People
How to Learn, Teach, and Influence People
By Keith F. McAdams
Knowledge is valuable.
But possessing more knowledge does not automatically make someone a better teacher, coach, parent, or leader.
Sometimes the person doing the teaching knows so much that the real challenge becomes deciding what not to say.
A coach may see ten things an athlete could improve. That does not mean the athlete needs to hear all ten.
A teacher may understand every detail of a subject. That does not mean every detail belongs in today's lesson.
A leader may understand the entire problem. That does not mean everyone needs the entire explanation before taking the next action.
This is where wisdom becomes important.
Knowledge can be extensive.
Understanding makes it relevant.
Wisdom determines what to use, when to use it, and how much to use.
Influence focuses the person on the next action.
Execution makes it real.
The value of knowledge is not measured by how much you can communicate.
It is measured by whether you can use what you know to help someone take the right next action.
The One-Minute Test
Consider a timeout in a hockey game.
You may have approximately one minute.
Five skaters and a goalie are looking at you.
As the coach, you may possess years of knowledge. You understand your system, the opponent's tendencies, the score, the clock, your personnel, the forecheck, defensive coverage, and several tactical possibilities.
But those six players do not need everything you know.
They need what matters now.
That changes the question from:
How much do I know?
to:
What do these six players need from me for the next action?
Much of the education should already have occurred.
The players have learned the system.
They have practiced the situations.
They understand the terminology.
They have made similar decisions in practice.
The timeout is usually not the place to start teaching the entire concept again.
It is an opportunity to retrieve what has already been learned and direct attention toward what matters next.
And there is no requirement to use the entire minute.
If ten seconds accomplishes the purpose, you don't need sixty.
That is wisdom in using knowledge.
The Athlete Doesn't Need Everything the Coach Knows
The coach may need extensive knowledge and understanding to make a good decision.
The athlete often needs something much simpler to execute it.
Imagine a defenseman retrieving a puck under pressure.
During education, we can explain why the player should scan before reaching the puck.
How many forecheckers are coming?
Where is the pressure?
Where is the support?
What is open?
What information can the goaltender provide?
There is considerable knowledge underneath the action.
During execution, however, the player might need only:
Check your shoulder.
The short instruction does not replace the education.
It retrieves it.
That distinction is essential.
The simplicity used during competition should be built during education and practice.
Too Much Instruction Can Interfere With Skill
The same principle applies when teaching physical skills.
Consider skating.
A knowledgeable coach can see knee bend, hip position, balance, edges, stride direction, recovery, posture, timing, stick position, and numerous other components.
The coach may be correct about all of them.
But the athlete does not necessarily need all of those corrections at the same time.
Research on attentional focus in motor learning provides support for being deliberate about how instructions direct an athlete's attention. Studies frequently find advantages when attention is directed toward the intended movement effect rather than requiring the performer to consciously control numerous body movements. The exact effect depends on the task, learner, and instructional context, so this should not be treated as a universal rule. (PubMed Central (PMC))
The practical coaching question becomes:
What is the smallest manageable component I can address right now that can positively influence the entire movement?
That might be hockey position.
Hockey position is foundational because it influences multiple things.
Knee bend affects balance.
It affects reach while stickhandling.
It affects movement.
It affects the athlete's ability to react.
Rather than correcting everything simultaneously, wisdom identifies what matters most now and builds from there.
Simplification is not necessarily evidence of less knowledge. Done well, it can demonstrate deeper understanding.
You have to understand the whole well enough to know which part matters first.
Environment → Mastery → Compete
This is one reason the three containers used throughout this book matter:
Environment → Mastery → Compete
Environment
Create the conditions for learning.
Introduce the knowledge, terminology, expectations, and behaviors.
Explain the why.
Allow questions.
Give the learner enough information to begin understanding what is being developed.
Mastery
Now develop it.
Break the whole into manageable components.
Practice.
Repeat.
Correct.
Connect Keywords and Terms to the behaviors they represent.
Gradually require the athlete to recognize situations and make decisions.
Compete
Now the athlete must retrieve and execute what has already been learned.
The environment is faster.
Time is shorter.
Pressure increases.
Decisions matter.
Communication therefore often needs to become more precise.
Before the pressure: educate and build understanding.
During development: practice and build mastery.
Under pressure: clarify and influence the next action.
A Keyword Can Carry Knowledge
This is why I have long used Keywords and Terms in coaching.
A keyword can be one familiar word that directs the athlete's attention back to a much larger body of previously learned knowledge.
One example is:
READ.
Consider forechecking.
Before a player can select the appropriate tactic, he has to read what is happening.
Who has the puck?
Who is going to win the race to the puck?
Is it a 50-50 puck?
Does our team have possession?
Does the opponent have possession?
Those questions matter because possession helps determine whether we are acting offensively or defensively and which tactic applies.
During education and practice, I might repeatedly ask:
Are you reading the play?
Who has the puck?
Who is going to get the puck?
Over time, I may not need to ask every question.
I can say:
READ.
The athlete has learned what sits behind that word.
That is what gives the keyword its power.
A keyword becomes powerful not because it says a lot, but because the athlete has learned a lot behind the word.
Research on motor learning supports the broader principle that verbal instructions and cues can direct attention during skill performance. However, the exact words Keywords and Terms are my coaching terminology and application of that broader principle. (PubMed Central (PMC))
A Term Can Carry an Entire Team Principle
A term can carry even more information.
One of our defensive principles is:
READ • COMMUNICATE • PRESSURE UP • CONTAIN
This is not four consecutive instructions given to one player.
It is a common language for the entire defensive unit.
The players read the developing play.
They communicate what they see and their responsibilities.
When the situation allows, one player pressures up on the puck carrier while other players protect the middle and contain their responsibilities.
For example, a defenseman may see the developing rush first.
A backchecker coming through the middle may recognize that he can track an offensive player. He communicates that responsibility. That information can allow the defenseman to pressure the puck carrier while the other players protect the middle and contain.
The play can develop differently.
The backchecker may pick up and contain his man while the defenseman pressures up on the puck carrier. The backchecker and the other defenseman continue protecting the middle and containing as the play develops.
If the play continues toward the goal, everyone ultimately identifies his responsibility, picks up his man, and contains.
The same terminology can carry into defensive-zone play.
The exact responsibilities change according to what the players read.
The words stay the same. The responsibilities change with the read.
Four familiar concepts can therefore retrieve an entire defensive principle.
That is possible because the knowledge underneath those words was taught before the game.
Build the Meaning Before You Need the Word
A coach cannot simply invent a keyword during a game and expect it to carry all that meaning.
The meaning has to be developed beforehand.
With READ • COMMUNICATE • PRESSURE UP • CONTAIN, we educate the players on what the concepts mean and then practice them.
We can begin by repeating a particular situation.
The players learn the responsibilities and recognize the pattern.
Then we change the patterns.
Eventually, situations become less predictable.
Now the players cannot simply perform a predetermined response.
They have to read.
From there, we can move into game-type drills where speed, pressure, transitions, opponents, and decision-making become increasingly realistic.
Finally, the principle has to carry into the game itself.
My coaching progression can be summarized as:
Teach → Blocked Repetition → Pattern Recognition → Random Situations → Game-Type Drills → Game
Research on contextual interference provides qualified support for varying practice structure. Random or higher-contextual-interference practice can benefit retention and transfer, but the effects depend heavily on age, task, and setting. Recent meta-analyses found stronger effects in laboratory and adult populations and much weaker or uncertain effects in applied settings and younger participants. Therefore, the progression above is a coaching framework, not a claim that research has established one universal sequence for every athlete. (PubMed Central (PMC))
The larger principle remains:
Simple game communication is the result of extensive preparation.
A Drill Name Can Carry Knowledge
The same idea can be designed into drills.
Consider familiar bookend drills such as:
Two-Man Passing.
Three-Man Passing.
Four-Man Passing.
Once players have learned these drills, the name itself carries information.
The players know how to organize.
They know what the drill entails.
They know the established behaviors expected during execution.
The name is not the complete instruction.
The name retrieves instruction that has already been learned.
Inside the passing drill there may also be established Keywords and Terms:
See the puck.
Control your stick.
Make eye contact.
Communicate.
Accelerate.
If one component deteriorates, I do not necessarily have to stop the entire drill and deliver another explanation.
A familiar keyword can redirect attention.
The correction can occur without unnecessarily destroying the flow of the drill.
Again, the word works because the education came first.
Wisdom Builds Simplicity Before Simplicity Is Needed
Simple communication under pressure should not depend on suddenly finding the perfect words during the game.
It should be designed beforehand.
The concept was taught.
Understanding was developed.
The behavior was practiced.
The Keywords and Terms were established.
The behavior was repeated.
The athlete had opportunities to make decisions.
Then, when time becomes limited and pressure increases, very little may need to be said.
Educate → Understand → Practice → Retrieve → Execute
Wisdom organizes knowledge so it can be retrieved when it is needed.
This applies far beyond hockey.
A teacher can establish terminology that retrieves a previously learned process.
A leader can use familiar language to activate an established procedure.
A parent can use a familiar phrase that reminds a child of something already taught and practiced.
Wisdom doesn't wait until the game to simplify the message. It builds the knowledge, language, and repetitions in practice so the message can be simple when the game becomes complex.
Knowing When to Stop Talking
One of the biggest mistakes a coach can make is to keep talking.
You see it at the coaching board.
The coach makes the important point.
Then he continues explaining.
And explaining.
And explaining.
Eventually, the important instruction can become buried underneath everything that followed it.
Influence is not measured by how long you can hold the floor.
It is measured by whether people receive what they need and can act on it.
Get to the point. Keep the instruction precise. Make it clear. Then let the players execute.
Sometimes that requires an explanation.
Sometimes it requires one sentence.
Sometimes it requires one familiar keyword.
READ.
Then stop talking.
The principle is not that shorter communication is always better.
The principle is:
Don't use more words simply because you possess more knowledge. Use what is necessary to produce understanding and action.
Make Your Communication Count
There is another reason I try to limit how long I talk to players.
It doesn't mean I don't want to communicate with them.
I want the communication to count.
When I enter the locker room, I want to bring energy into the room.
I want the players to feel that what we are about to discuss matters.
Then I want to get to the point.
A game plan might contain five important things.
Between periods, I may address three.
I may address only one.
The question isn't:
What else can I tell them?
It is:
What do they need right now?
Make the point.
Make it clear.
Bring the appropriate energy to it.
Then stop.
I also want to leave players some time to digest what was said before they go back onto the ice.
That silence is part of the communication.
If I continually fill the locker room with words—talking simply because I have something else I could say—I can eventually lose the room.
Important messages begin to sound like everything else.
A season is long.
There will be hundreds of opportunities to communicate.
You don't have to use all of them.
Attention matters.
Wisdom therefore involves deciding not only what to communicate, but how much, with what energy, at what time, and when to stop.
Bring the energy.
Identify what matters.
Keep it precise.
Give people room to process.
Then let them execute.
The purpose isn't to communicate less.
The purpose is to make your communication worth listening to.
Clarity Before Complexity
This brings us back to an earlier principle in this book:
Clarity Before Complexity.
Complex knowledge can be valuable during education.
But complexity should eventually produce greater clarity—not permanent dependence on more explanation.
The knowledgeable coach may be capable of explaining everything.
The wise coach knows what needs explaining.
The knowledgeable coach sees every mistake.
The wise coach identifies what should be addressed now.
The knowledgeable coach possesses the information.
The wise coach organizes that information so someone else can use it.
And the influential coach eventually helps the athlete act without needing another speech.
A Simple Self-Evaluation
After teaching, coaching, leading, parenting, or trying to influence someone, don't ask only:
Was I right?
Ask:
Did I give this person the information they needed—or simply the information I knew?
Then:
Did what I said help them take the next right action?
And:
Did I stop talking when the message was clear?
Those questions move the scorecard away from how much the teacher knows and toward what the learner can actually do.
That is where influence becomes visible.
The Principle
Knowledge matters.
Understanding matters.
But neither guarantees effective influence.
You have to know how to use them.
Sometimes wisdom means explaining more.
Sometimes it means breaking a complex skill into one manageable component.
Sometimes it means teaching an athlete everything that sits behind one word:
READ.
Sometimes it means building a common team language:
READ • COMMUNICATE • PRESSURE UP • CONTAIN
Sometimes it means practicing a situation repeatedly before introducing greater unpredictability and eventually carrying the learning into competition.
Sometimes it means calling the name of a familiar drill.
Sometimes it means entering a locker room with energy, delivering one important message, and then giving the players time to digest it.
And sometimes, with five skaters and a goalie looking at you and only a minute available, wisdom means saying very little.
Because the objective isn't to show people everything you know.
The objective is to use what you know to help them take the next right action.
Supporting Evidence
Motor learning and attentional focus: Research has repeatedly examined how instructions direct a performer's attention. A 2024 systematic review and network meta-analysis of sport-specific motor skills found that attentional-focus strategies can affect motor performance and learning, while outcomes vary according to the particular strategy, task, and study conditions. (PubMed Central (PMC))
Instructions and feedback: Research with younger learners also supports treating the form, timing, and frequency of instruction as meaningful variables rather than assuming that simply providing more feedback is always better. However, a systematic review involving children found mixed evidence for several specific feedback strategies, reinforcing the need to avoid universal prescriptions. (PubMed Central (PMC))
Blocked and random practice: A 2024 systematic review and meta-analysis found an overall transfer advantage for higher-contextual-interference/random practice, but the effect in applied settings was small and statistically nonsignificant, and the effect among young participants was negligible. (PubMed Central (PMC))
Retention: A separate 2024 meta-analysis found a beneficial overall effect of high contextual interference on retention, but again found that benefits were much weaker in applied settings and young participants. This supports using practice variability thoughtfully rather than treating random practice as universally superior. (PubMed Central (PMC))
Application to this article: Teach → Blocked Repetition → Pattern Recognition → Random Situations → Game-Type Drills → Game is Keith F. McAdams' coaching framework. The research above supports several underlying motor-learning principles, but does not establish this exact sequence as a universal scientific formula.
Tags
Wisdom, Influence, Coaching, Teaching, Communication, Motor Learning, Athlete Development, Practice Design, Leadership, World Championship Habits
© 2026 Keith F. McAdams. All rights reserved.
Comments
Post a Comment